The phone rang while I was in the middle of fixing dinner, and offered a town hall style phone meeting. I’ve heard these before, our Congresswoman Kay Granger holds them occasionally. I pushed “O” to get into the queue to ask Hutchison a question, and then was treated to 30 minutes of Republican party propaganda and scare tactics, with softball questions lobbed her way by party members with down-home local accents, posting concerned questions about the end of Health Care As We Know It. Heaven forbid that women have the choice or coverage for abortion services, or that a public option be considered. And that precious “doctor/patient relationship” – you know, the one that your insurance company dictates with an iron fist – that was at risk.
It didn’t take long to figure out Democrats weren’t going to get to talk on this call. While at first I figured they must have dialed my phone by accident, after listening to the production values of the “meeting,” I am more convinced that it was a devious plan to try to make me listen to their political nonsense and be swayed by it. The only thing missing at the end was “This political ad was paid for by the elect Hutchinson for Governor campaign.”
What production values? The same ones that come into play on talk radio programs. I am familiar with those on KERA-FM, public radio. If I’m waiting to speak, I’m listening to the conversation seven seconds old. That delay is so if someone totally inappropriate comes on, they can zap it before it ever gets onto the air. Each of Kay’s “callers” was confused as to whether they were being spoken to because, it seems, they were listening to the delayed conversation, and the voice breaking in 7 seconds before the previous call ended was confusing.
But this could be a tactic also, to make it sound real. Because I’m convinced it wasn’t. I think it was a staged program in which Democrats were called but not allowed to talk. It is my hunch that the Hutchison campaign hoped to run their party line past the listening Democrats, trying to scare them with the “don’t let government take over health care” claims, and the suggestion that Canada and the United Kingdom have terrible health care. They don’t–it is actually quite good. And if you think those countries have “rationing,” just look at what American insurance companies are doing. They’re practicing medicine without a license, and they’re rationing, based upon what they will or won’t pay for.
What was I going to ask? I wanted to tell her to listen to this constituent–I want her to vote for this health care reform plan, not drag her feet to prevent progress. And I wanted to suggest she sit down in a one-on-one conversation with Dennis Kucinich and really learn what the issues are.
So I think she needs to come clean. Mrs. Hutchison, that wasn’t REALLY a town hall meeting, was it? That was a prolonged political trick to try to scare rational people into thinking Republicans have been shut out of the process (you walked away from it of your own free will, M’am) and that the reforms being proposed will end life as we know it.
Yes, I hope indeed that it does. And when 30 million additional people in America finally get health coverage, and the rest of us get fair coverage, and small businesses suddenly can compete on a more level playing field because in one way or another everyone will have health insurance, I think we’ll see a lot of other things improve for everyone. Too bad you chose not to be a part of it, Kay.
